It would be cheaper to buy it wholesale. It would be easier to outsource production. But some things are worth doing the hard way.
The Easy Way Out
Let's be transparent about something: making our own ice cream is not the efficient choice. We could call up a distributor, order pallets of perfectly acceptable commercial ice cream, and save ourselves a significant amount of time, labor, and money. Hundreds of restaurants do exactly that, and their customers never know the difference.
We know the difference. And once you know, you can't unknow it.
What "House-Made" Actually Means
When we say we make our own ice cream, we mean it literally. Our recipe, our ingredients, our production. We control every step of the process, from the dairy we source to the final product that goes into your Awful Awful. That level of control allows us to maintain a consistency that simply isn't possible when you're relying on a third party.
Our ice cream has a higher butterfat content than most commercial products. That means it's richer, creamier, and more flavorful. It also means it behaves differently in an Awful Awful — it blends thicker, holds its texture longer, and delivers that signature density that separates an Awful Awful from every other milkshake.
The Recipe
We're not going to share it. Sorry. But we will tell you this: the recipe hasn't changed dramatically since the early days. Minor refinements here and there as ingredient quality and equipment improved, but the fundamental formula — the ratios, the process, the philosophy — has remained remarkably consistent.
That's by design. When something works, you protect it. You don't change it because a trend told you to. You don't tweak it because a consultant suggested a cheaper alternative. You make the same ice cream, the same way, because that's what your customers trust you to do.
The Cost of Compromise
Every restaurant faces this tension: quality versus efficiency. Making your own ice cream costs more. It requires dedicated equipment, skilled staff, and constant attention to process. It would be so much easier to just order boxes from a warehouse.
But here's what happens when you compromise on the foundation: everything built on top of it suffers. The Awful Awful tastes different. The sundaes lose their edge. The thing that makes you special becomes the same as everybody else. And once you lose that, you can't get it back.
Nearly 100 Years and Counting
We've been making our own ice cream since 1928. That's not just a tradition — it's a promise. A promise that when you walk into a Newport Creamery, the ice cream in your glass is ours. Made by us, for you, with the same care and stubbornness that's kept this recipe alive for nearly a century.
Some things are worth doing the hard way.
Tags